L6» IJ < # = 5 # H, G? C D D F D # E9? CB < # ' ' 53 9R ; ;A 2 N: 8 2D Q C., G

Transkript

1 ,-./ 1397 $%&' 4 "# 48 :!" # $59: ; $59: ; 1 7" % 7"823 43?5%@ %<= > (96/11/4 : 96/10/9 ) A L6» IJ <# = 5# H,G?CDDF D # E9?CB<# ' '53 9R ;;A 2N: 8 2D QC. $9O - 3 = 7DN: «,G L6,G ' STG?5U 5D 3D' 3 = 5#,G 2D?CDDF 2D D5U 3 N&?5%3?5DLF2N: 3G,G L6 C $ C.,G D5U 5%3 2N: 3G O 2D %#?= V2D 3.,G ' 9.?5;'3 Y%& & '5 XF "823 E%&?;W F,G L6 J5 [ 2D 53. H $9O '5 IG 3 T % L6 C7#?C.8Z L6 ] I: 3 7"823 E%&?5NC 3 6 T:5& 53 E@ H<5\ IJ $= 8 EU 3 $ 7# '5 E%& - G 8 >C^F _. = 5# %G 2A?5NC D5= ;DF 53 : 3 D5U &3@ 3D' `"@?C_ D5U '.% 7# D5%,I8H & Z (UNCTAD) 7 $' I :,: a5.@ 9O b3?c. (SIPRI) E9% e/.'?"c,g ',G L6 N&,G N\?5353?@ $6f shirkhani@ut.ac.ir.1

2 1397 $%&' 4 "# ;" +"9:.;#. ' +/. +*"8( 7.&6 4#5 0123"%/.,- +*#()' %&!" #$ B/@CD!" E F ;/; G5& 49@?8( E&= /. %/@A +"&.. ;" <=' >&? 95 ' N *? 4+"8( %/L M:N OP. ;" &//J K B/H/;I 2;9. U&;?.. /*"S #T/N %/L +&R*" Q5!" #? +*#I ' - #*; XT; &. ED +"8(&/VW &@( ' /2*" 9. 9F. &/S" +*; %/L +* /1.= Y9. 9@?8(.D# 2?9. #2@/; "8( %" &/J@ %& 4+"9:T ' #1123"%/. 0Z 40/3 %/2* 9.. ;" [. ["&2* \F ' [2] O]!. #*"8( %/L 2Z Q;&I %& 9. [D ED? #32@K" O"&/VW ' [N@ O^". %/L +&R*" ' +$2* 9. [*0$? +*9H3` ' 0123"%/.,- #_@- E"&/I 0123"%/. ;/;. ;" [? 0R 9]!!" #2 QA. 9@?8( 7* L #"&(U="' ' /3"&R/3 #2""I O"&a 9$". #(!9. 4 ;" [" c@s" S 9. Q;&I %" 9. ;I " 0123"%/. b."' +&- E2@H( #_A;I +"&. B/2@/; +*+.9@; 9. +&@d/. 9F S E2@H( E' E"&(U="' 7!"» 7&- ' 4E/ %".(DiCicco & Levy, 2003: 109) "[" Ed [? Q;&I 9. ' %/L +&R*" OCZ!" +&- +*%//R %&[?9@S?!" «O= "8(» ' «O= %2i?# gc h;" %" &.. ;" E F ;/; N 9. /;D 0R ' [N@ O^" 49]! ' +$2* ' &//J MT 7/! [? +&- &$' ' #.!" ' #;&. [N@ O^" ' %/L.= &I OCZ D ' /;D O= "8( "& # L b"&? 95 ;" ED 93: %" ^@;".? #;&. O= "8( +&- &$' +R&. j/i +"&. +&@d/. %//R /1.= 4O= 7!" 7&- 9. R O= "8( 7&- 4#1Z." /;D k&? 7:T G/ ' O= +*#I 7&. lll 9@&(OP +*Q*')I 7/d/I 9. #32F" #*_. 4K%". Organski, 1958; Organski & Kugler, 1980 ) *Q*')I %" 95 /.# O= "8( #d*')i (; Kim, 1991, 1992, 1996 ; Lemke & Warner, 1996 ; Kugler & Lemke, 1996 ; Lemke, 2002 #3K 4&_ OR]9.. ;" [. #@R 0123"%/.,-!" #TS ' #@; +*0/1N &. &@d/. Z %" 4O= "8( ' * O= E/ +&."&. /Zi' Z "= 7!" 95 "8( 7&- 9$". ' &/(# m'&h O= B 9T1; ' +&&. " #(/n/i 9. 9F. +&- &$' ' &* 4*# Ed O= #I 9. +&@d/. 9F O= 95 +"9(9. 4*# @" #2 4#5 0123"%/.,-

3 1003 H 2D?CDDF :5F,G L6 'EA : = 5#,G L6 '%"!".@/ /;D k&? 7:T ' 0123"%/. ;/;!'&" /; ' [/n/i /* +_A;I %2i 4O= "8( #@; +*9H3` +R&. O= "8( "& #;&.!" pi &ik 73: +*#(/n/i ' *#I +R&. " "8( %" +* 3^ 4% +*qs? #S&. E'G" ' O= 7!" 7&- ' A 4h;" %" &..*# Ed 9:T ' 0123"%/. ;/; % #;&. 0123"%/. ;/; &//J %//R B &* &55 ' [? #.!" O= "8( # H O"G3" 4[/n/I +*@/; Oi'&H ' P" &. 9/$. 4ED!" pi.?# A@ 7&- +*qs? ' *&/J@ 4pr;.? *"S X&T O= "8( 7&- +!;!. Oi'&H ' [? 9@. 59. #.&6 OP9. 4/;D k&? 7:T 4O= "8( 493: MT &. ED +* 3^ 4Z. QA..? *"S [?" B &* 0s [/n/i +*@/;.? *"S 9o"" 93: +&/(96/@ 4 ' [? [" Ed /;D k&? O= "8( &; \F E"' 0123"%/. 9$"..( @/3).1 /" ' j1p 7/! *9&- %&!" "= 7!" 7&- # 2?9. [' ED B/5D 0N +&$ lll %& 95. b; pr; ' %' 9&- b;,' # F \F!" pi 9&- %" ' +!;!.!" pi 4? 0/2$ R/ ' /25 4&6//5 4E'D 4%2$r;" EL #"&$H@ [_F 9. (1979) 0123"%/. ;/; 7&- l@5 G@3"' b; ED!" #2@/; #//R ' &; \F EI. 9&- %" 4K%"..(1387 4%/r1/( w @/3) O^" 0.: 9!" 9(&* %@&_!" #yz. 95 #F w ;" [? 0R 0$? 7o"" ; R= 0.= +&- %/n2* ' ED!" Z. O]i ' x"k *9&- %&G/_"&.9d=!" #$ 9. 4[N@ {R&: " &; \F!" pi b"&? 9&- %" #//R O= 4#$z&. E"!"&I9&-.(9 : @/3) "[&5 #&Z G/L!" 4*# 0$? ls +!"&I9&- 9. #]2@F",1] lll 95 " #3P" 9nL 4&/_. &- 4# 1]L #_Lr$ ' #I 4#.&6 = 4#F9&P 4+&-,6" 912F ] &-!" 95 O= 7!" 7&- >CS&. "&! w" +&@d/. /."8F O= "8( 7&- k +!"&I9&- +*#()' 4 ;" [? 9F" [&@( O":@". [? +*/Z E&$ +&- +*%//R %&+=!" 4E"&_1/1N!" +/. /:] "9(9. w ;"" #.S9. " Lemke & ) ;" 9@?" 0123"%/. 9]! ' +$2* /= +*9&- E/ " #.&6 ' ' % +*gc F'. 9@R3".(Werner, 1996; DiCicco & Levy, 2004; Tammen et al, 2000,

4 1397 $%&' 4 "# %" +&$ +*9d 4 #"&(U="' #&Z E F ;/; l@5.!" O= "8( 7&- E&5 "F +"&. (2000) Q"$2* ;" [D&. #"&(U="' #2""I E' O"&a!" 9&- (Organski, 1958) #$(" b; "@." O= "8( 7&- 7&- ED!" Z. /ZT=,] ' # F +*\F O"&//J!" &VW@ 4l@5 %" +'.? "8( 7&- X&Y. ' /d5 Q3L 9. E F ;/; &8I&//J E= E"]9. " O= 7!" +"&. +&@. 0/1N +R O= 7!" 7&-. 9:» 'D *"& " #.LL O= ' #5 = R &. * '" :.(Organski, 1958: 300) * 9o"" [D U='!" E!D 0.= ' #:T +*[3? R &. * ' O= 7!", H G/_"&.91 O= "8( 7&- %/. m'&h 9;.(Organski, 1958) #/.Q/I.5. "@;" +&-, H %" :!" ;" OR] ~/P 9. 0o= 9$1. 4/.#2 B/?D " 4O= 7!" 7&- >CS&. 4 A ' BL5 +*O= 4G. +*O= 4b1 O=!" 0$d@ 4 ;" #R"&911; #2- mz ' " "&= b1 O= E"] N +K"' 3' /@S" ED & 95 4#:. ' #RV#. ' mz 9. b1 3' ' ( a +*O=) E"&_d3L %/. #:1 E)* 4b1 O= 9@R3".(Organski, 1958)? \F & ' &@5 9. = # 9. 9.d ON/F&. #*. 9$23 hc(" 4%/n2* 4# E' 9_L 95 " Ed "&! 4(B/)* ORV 7&- ;" %$2 "F %" >CS&.)?#2 1 >C@o" & ' 0/$d. " g"9t1; 9$1. 4 / 0123"%/..(Kugler & Tammen,2009: 36; Lim, 2015 : 22) «#NT;L "&911;» 5# HK S, H E&5 "' O?9. "&911; %" E' OCZ 9@R3"." F' G/ +"9:T "&911; +2? "8_. &V" &. "#2 &_@"* %/"= 4#"&(U="' #;/; +*['&( 2* * 4S 7&- ' ;" # F >CS&. 4O= "8( "&911;!" &VW@.(Lemke, 2002) 7&- 4,' 1 ED 95 "# * 9.d {;;" " 0123"%/. ' #1S".@* 0123"%/.,- l/25 U. &; &. o".= 7!" E"!"&I9&- 95 EnD " D E/.= ' * /.# q3s +*'@; Q"G" 95 4O= 1 >* 4O= "8( 7&- 4,; +!;9/d/. 9 4" E]s" O= 4#"&(U="' E&F E' +*9&- %&!" #S&.. O= "8( 7&- +&$ Oi'&H O'H E&2?&.. ED.1.#"&(U="' * "&= #"&(&S 0s " 9&- %" *# j/f&

5 1005 H 2D?CDDF :5F,G L6 'EA : = 5#,G L6 #1 O= &//J 4#R]9..(Organski & Kugler, 1980: ; DiCicco & Levy,2003) * 3' E/ b."' O"&//J &N " E? #@ZP ' #"&(#1 +*[G/_" 76/@.5# N@ " 0123"%/. ;/; S 95 9@" ' #2F ' #Z" #"&(U="' 4G@3"' #"&(U="' 4B/;C5 #"&(U="' 4h;" %" &. 9L&( 4D# lk9. O= 7!" +*9&- 2? 92* B/;C5 #"&(U="' %" &/(# 0$? 95 #3"`; ".(DiCicco & Levy, 2003: 110) " >C@S" *. O/oGF &. 9/$. O= "8( 7&- ƒ?# &6 9]! ' +$2* 9. b"&? %" 9_L 95 ;" Ui'!" +2@i E"G/» ' (Overtaking) «%@F #d/i» 4(Parity) «+&."&.» +/15 &/J@ 9; 7S&L 9. ZP +"&. &_d3l O= gc ED 95 5# ~/P " #T"&? «F.6"# +$2* ' 9]! E$" 9. O= #= "# I +"[I " O= #:1 ' O= 7!" 7&- :. #$(" &T? +!. En2* 0123"%/. -.5# 9.&6 " "'! ' 1. 4? 0K"& ED 95 #;;" /2*" *>C@o" O"&//J '?..V ED E"&_d5 O= 95 / *d5 &;"&;? & >C@S"!" #? +I O^N. ["&2* 9$1. 4?. 9@?" \F m'&h. 4'%"!".(Kugler & Organski, 1980 :176)?# O^N L 4E! Y ^@;" 4 ;" &//J K o" Y9. "&911; 95 /Z="' %" %@&( b1 O=. +&."&. 9. &_d3l B 95?# 6" #@=' mz 95?# #! (1980) &1(5 ' #$(" [(!" G/ +&."&. %" /Z.(Lim, 2015: 284) ;# P 20 ;&. b1 O= +*+2" E"G/ P &_d3l 3' 95 ;".(Kugler & Organski, 1980 :176) (% ) &/( #d/i ED!" '&? 9R1ˆ ' +&."&. 95 " Ed +Z. O:/:N 49/3'" +*5 >CS&. 4K%". Kugler & ) D#2 lk9. (B/)* \F) [2] \F <'&? +"&. #5 #3' 4",!^ F Ui'!" &_d3l O= i 7F 9. 9@.» 4&_ OR]9. O:/:N +*9@.(Lim, 2015: 284).(1980 Organski, G/Dj1P "8( \F 9. "8( ;" %$2. (1996) /5 ' (1997) #r1œ( 4(1996) &' ' &1(5 4(1996) &' ' 9$23 4(1995) +Š E/ F Ui'!" #H #.!" 95 " Ed O= "8( 7&- \F 7/i&.5 496/@.O= +&."&. >&ŒP " 9]! 2@K" &. +&@d/. &V" G. O= +* HF #_F Ž/* 4?. 9@?" 0123"%/. F Ui'!" R #.!" a O= 95 #T"&? OZ3T %" 72* 4#15 Y9..*#2 b1 O= ' a O= %/. "8(

6 1397 $%&' 4 "# ]! 2@K" 95 "# #5&TS b"&? " F Ui'!" #@i ' +&."&.!" +*"?.*# Q"G" "!"# $%.2 #;&. O= "8( 7&- la@" 01] +( "# [? OH/P <26 B/)*.= + E"]9. %/L a E5".?. <=' >&? O= +*#I %" a!" (1958) #$(" #/.Q/I M:N &_2 E"&a #S&. +;!" /;D k&? 95 " #R6Z b"&? %". ;" [D &_d3l O= E"]9. d5 7Ad 4K%"..?. 9@&( 0$? O= "8( 7&- 9. 9=C] * HF "8( &. 95 " O= "8(, H!" #@;?"&. 4#TS&/ˆ ' [/n/i /* 0/39. +*[!K 72* b1 O= +&&. ' 9T1; ED ' ;" #@R +!;!. 9.!/ '!;# "5 4?# 2]" #21] ' #_*& 4#@/" 4#;/; 4+@=" # H +*E/. 7I&. 9/! %".da.# O'&i " #(/n/i O^Z 7I&. # H [/n/i +*@/; 7&- Oi'&H ' P" %&9@F&. 4l?D ' #(/n/i 7&- :!" "OR] [/n/i +*@/; ORV 76/@ E&5 02] #TS&/ˆ ' #I.1 w5# 02] #3Z 7T:!" ' 9. ' l?d 7R3 ["2* 95"&L w ;" 8('! +&" ' +@ 7@;D +"" *@/; 95 ;" <i %" &_/ E? +"9S? 0P".2 &/ 9"" E" 4+"9:T ' # F +*d Q"G" b"&? 95 +"9(9. 4"02N!" #? "# 95 #*d..# k; - E? +"9S? 2;9. ' " " #1R=. - E? +"9S? 4b"&? %".?. &n35oz B/5"oz 4B/@/1Ioz +*#()' +*- 0S" ' #(/n/i 9. 9:T #' - E? +Z.L *@/;[&S +&/(0$? w.# k; #3Z : Z ' +"9:T ' # F %$2 #(&( %&BL5 ED 95 ;" #@/Zi' &_/. 95 hk #_@."' 0P".3 w?. 9@?" #TS&/ˆ +*/I ;". #2/:@ #_@R2* 4&//J E"G/ >CS&. 95 O= E= 0P".4 " +! O"&//J 4BL5 #3N ' 5 +z&". #@K [( 40/3 %/2* 9.." O= E"G/ w? *"S O= B/ E? #TS&/ˆ R; S 95 &5 [*d E"# O= +*9S&L ' "&911; Z ' < &_/. 95 #!* ' < 0P".5.5# 02] E?r2* ' E!* OP9. K%/] 95 ;" +"9:T ' # F XT;

7 1007 H 2D?CDDF :5F,G L6 'EA : = 5#,G L6 0R ' B/5"oz ' B/@/1Ioz +*B/ #?I* ' #!* E"# 4ED &.['C] #- A; O= 7I&. &_ O= 4#R]9..&5 [*d " E" 9. D OP9. '.# 2 G/ #_*& ' +@=" 4#;/; +*3= 9$1. 4?#2 ~&Z.5# 02] *. 02$ 9T1; &_ 9@?8( ; +*@/; >CS&. 95 [/n/i +*@/; E: R 0P".6 4O= E? +Z.L. 9$1. 4?#2 [*d #;/; O/K ~1@A Z." 72* +&&. ' "&911;,] ED Mrotzek, ) 7Ad ;" %$2 ~1@A #]i +*[!K '?# [ E:,] #] %& 95 #5.( : 1393 w :1391 4#2;=) &/( 0$? +Z@ /n/i /* 4/& %" 9. ;" O= E. +Z.L ' #(5"&I 4hK #_@."' 4E. /; 4 /ZT= Z 95 " O= "8(!" #@; 0/1N 9. ' &.# "`; &! 4 4(2011; Cudworth & Hobden, 2010 &(# m'&h #;/; O/K Z." 72* ' O= B 7T1; ' E? @" #1/1N +"9S? " "8( 4(1393 +*9S&L %@?" E: 4#2;=) «O= B/ 5 OYR" U! +_3" %@ /2*" ' < 0/39. 6" R; 95 / F" +"9:T ' # F #2;=) E"]9. O= "8( : Z. 95 Z %" 9. 7$R? #NT;L "&911;.5# O= #; Z ' "8( ' &; \F +@ +_3"» O= "8( +*qs? ' +*&/J@?# gc 9"".?# (1393 S 95? 9@&( 59. #.&6 Y9. ' [? #.!" /;D k&? 9&- %" A; 7@*. ;" 9:T %/L 9. "z!" ' E F %/L 9. [N@ O^"!" O= "8( "& +(, -+! )*+ & '(!.3 N E! Y 95 ;I +&" *K"' i ' O= 9&- %" 9$" 9. 9F. &R@Z 'D&. +"&. O= "8( #d*')i 7&. +/. #/12] ' +&- +*gc 4.# #;&. &; &. O= "8( E"&_d*')I E/ #15 Y9.. ;" 9@&(,6" *&/J@ %" O= #.!" +*qs? E"]9..(Organski, 1958: 203) (NNP) #1 q3s /3 (GNP) #1S" q3s /3? X&T #$(" >&Y!". %/@A 95 " F' <2F" #R ' 9@R3"." F' +2@i K #.!" +"&. #]2F" 0.= g'!* 4K%". 9@59. +*qs? 912F!".? 5 &@d/., H %" O/." [? gc &/S" 7* %/. >C@o" +/3H&I *R? 4#- +*9G* Z3"k? #;&. :!" "OR]

8 1397 $%&' 4 "# OC@S" 4#1123"%/. ' +"9:T Tammen et al, 2000; Lemke, 2002; Tammen & ) #1S" +*#I ' #! "& #Y * +* 5d 4b1 O= ' G. +*O= +6 'D,"G3" +*_3" F' ' #/!&;.(Kugler, 2009; Fravel, 2012; Lim, ' #R O= #.!" 4O= "8( 7&- /2*".5# " # F ' +"9:T "&911; #.O= &/ 4M:N OP 95 ;" #]=' >&? O= +*"8( ' N 91 %" B/H/;I/;D 7:T &/_2dL? 4ED +*9Ad %&9@F&.!"." ["&2*9. #2@/; #Z&;? @=" OKCP"!" pi %/L E/ %". 7&- E"&_1/1N 0/3 %/2* 9.. ;" &/S" 7* L #Y ;" +"9:T &_d3l = #1Z b"&? ' 9@?" #@K '& 4E F ' [N@ O^" +"&. #;;" Q3L 95 '. %" &. O= "8( a %/L ' [N@ O^" %/. U O!" S&. 9$1. 4. *"A +"9:T 7]! ' U=' D &-!".(Tammen & Kugler, 2009; Kang & Abdollahian, 2008). *"S += 9$1. 4" 9nD +"&. /;D k&? lf ' k&? <=' >&? O^N." /2*" # 9]!.= $&D +&R* D. ED +*/I +"&.!/0!.1. 3 ١ ' +@=" 0/@I 4 #/!&; qs? 9; h;"&. 93: %" #R O= #.!" [? /5W D &. G/ O= "8( 7&- +*#.!" 95 ;" [? 9R;N #- O= $'!'&!'& 5 $//' '!15!" 9@&(&. D!" B&* 'D&.. : ;" OP %" ;" ;" O=!" (2015) =O= 1ˆ" 4O= "8( #@; &$' 95 ;" ED $'!'& '!15 la@" 1] O= ' [? G5&2 * 1 #R O= 'D&. +"&. #1S" q3s /3 ' /Z2F 9. 9F. ".?# 9@&( &- F Ui'!" &_d3l +2@i #.!" G/ #- *d5 #R O=!" +&9/.U="' #.!" 95 [? ['G" #*qs? 4#5 b"&? 9. qs? ' ED 95 ;" #/!&; 0? A qs? 4 %".*# 9o"" qs?.?# #.!" E F 05 K&. 9("F B&* d5!"" ' /Z2F &#ogf " * 1 #FS /:@ +"8(9&; 4#1S" q3s /3 &.['C] +@=" 0/@I 4,' 1. Critical Mass

9 1009 H 2D?CDDF :5F,G L6 'EA : = 5#,G L6 9. ED :@" E' 9. *9&; l8f 95 ;" ED qs? %" /2*".&/(# &. G/ O= 4 S;&! 4+' :@" XT; En2* E.G/ d5 F b"&?!" +"[&@( O= #Z,; qs?." #_@. ;%"!" +" ' #Z/RY " ' U. 4+@=" #R O= #.!" #- O"P ' #] +*9G* &#ogf qs? '. #- ; K&. * 5 4M.; qs? ' >CS&. 4qS? Q? %". ;" [? N3 [?'D&. +*[".*# 0$? * 3' #R O= 9. 4E F jt; B&* (SIPRI) 1 $@;" j1p OZ3T 7;` ' # F B. +*[" [_I!" 9@&(&. &ik " [_I!" #FS /:@ +"8(9&; 9..& +*[" %/n2*. ;". ;" [? 9@&( (UNCTAD) +*; #Y d5 20 #R O=!" +'D&. $'!'& '!15 4&_ +;!" O= ' b1 O= [_F ' Q: 9. 9F. &ik 73: " w ;" [ a ' G. O= d* #R O= [D&. P 4O= "8( 7&- &_d3l 4E23D 4%/L 4%I"z 49/;' 4/@&. 4b1 O= E"]9. [N@ O^" 0? 95 ;" %" la@" %" /2*".5 #;& *; #Y " * ' 0!&. ["&2*9. #2@/; +*/I 4Ed= &@( 0/39. *d5 %" #R O= &//J 9(&* " [? +R &. *d5 %" #R O= &! "2.?" *"S :*# Ed?5l %= 9O b3?c ' $6;,N -.17#

10 1397 $%&' 4 "# E&= b1 O= En2* [N@ O^" 4?# [*d ^. 0$? 9nL? 4* ' %/L 4/;D. ;" Q*5 9. ' ED #R O= " 4# #=. $ ' /. ' /Z2F?. d5 ' %" 4O= "8(!""dL!" %"&.. w5# 9.&6 " +! Q3L 9. E F ;/; +&R* +"&. " [N@ O^" "# 4! #1S" q3s /3 *!" &^. ' [N@ O^"!" Z. %/L 4O= +*qs? &-!" 4#1Z b"&?.d$. 9$". 40.:. ;" [? &*a [N@ O^" &."&. &_d3l O= ' " "&= O= ;" ED!" &BL5 /. 4?# #:1 /;D #1P" O= En2* %I"z &H E/1/ 100 &! ; ED /Z2F 95 +"9(9. 4? 0R [D &_d3l 4?" " 9@F&. +"9:T Q: +H" +"&. +@=" /&a 95 ;" +d5 %I"z.;# $&D!" ED,'" /ZR 4ED 0/3 %/@A 95 ;" [S $? #d: %/L +H" " Q: *9H3` %" &. 9/$. 5# gc ' / 9F" #Z %/L. %/L 40.:. 2015; Beeson, 2009 ) 5 +!. /;D k&? " Z +"9:T +&R* +*+2"!" (2009) % ' &1(5 ' $'!'& 9.d [?!" #5K 4"G"# M/:N R@]" 9. 9$D &.['C] 95 ;" #R 7&- E"&_1/1N!" +/. 95 +"9(9. w ;" &_d3l B %/L #R O=? ;# [N@ O^". +&."& ; %/L 95 "[&5 #/.Q/I O= "8(.(Kugler & Tammen, 2009; Kang & Abdollahian, 2008) 12(3 4$!. 2. %" 2] E"&_d*')I +"&. 4F Ui' #.!" #.&6 qs? /2*" 9. 9F. F Ui'!" %" +&$ &@d/. 95 " 6Z +F +&$ Lemke & Werner,1996; Lemke, 2002; lim, 2015; E"]9. #- +*9G* Z3"k? 4? [?" 95 YE2* ' 9$23 hc(" 9.. +;!" ) ;" [d N3 &_d3l +2@i E"G/ #.!" 'D&. ;" [? 9@S? «F Ui' &//J 9. Z» +"&. #S? HK +"&. &_d3l Z9. #2@/; jt; " 4? +*9G*. Q"G" 4h;" %" ;" #i" O= 9. d5 %" 0R +*; %/. %/L #- &. +*9G* #.&6 +*0/1N.(DiCicco & Levy, *qs? 4( )!" #$ &' E"!; ;" %$2 &_d3l #- +*9G*!?» D /:]?"&. Q@/Z= '.(Lemke, 2002: *l!. *# ) &/S" «. 7* *"S ' #Y &//J Ed #2; +*D!" 9$23 9. /" jt; ED Z %/L #- +*#.!"

11 1011 H 2D?CDDF :5F,G L6 'EA : = 5#,G L6 #] 7F.. ;" 9@?" +&."&.[!"' {R&:? 4#2=' 7^;? ; " 4. (%/L I K"') #/R /1/ 55!" &@ ; %/L #2;.. *"S!? 9. ' ' 4? %" 4? 9:.(Lemke, 2002: 286) [N@ O^". %/L #- /; #/R /1/ *9G* #@=' &(,6" %/d/i QA : %" +R&. #- O= 'D&. ' [N@ O^"!" Z.,; 7R 95 +"9(9. 4*# Ed *; %" #Y " %/L 41 $@;" j1p OZ3T 7;` #2; +*D h;"&. %/n2*." "&= 9/;' E/;" G. 59G* %/' ' #] ON/1 #1P" 5%/W %/; 9. E ;!".(SIPRI Year Book, ; Military Balance, 2014: 252) ;" [? 0R E F #] F'. 4%/L ' [N@ O^" #- +*9G* %/. 71P 95 ;" ED!" #5K *'D&. %" K ]&; ;!" Z. $&D #- +*9G* #] 7F. [2] Q"G"!" "". #25 & G/ /;D k&? &_ +* /;D k&? +*.(SIPRI military data base ;SIPRI Year Book, 2017) ;" Q*5 1. %/L #- +*9G* 7: 1 #] 7F.."8(# +F&. +"9:T F Ui'!" %/L #@i 9. ON/1 :@" E&F 4%/n2*. ;" [. Q"G" 9. ' 9. 9@?8( 7* ' Y SIPRI Year ) *# Ed " +P 7/7 Q"G" %/. 9/;/=" ' /;D 7:T P 76!" Q/. +_A;I # 9. &/S" 7* ' Y %/L.(Book, 2015, 2016, 2017 #i" O= /Z= " d5 %" 95 ;" [. /;D k&? #- +*9G* Q"G" +*d5 9. 4/;D k&?!k Q"G" %&@d/. 4,&* h %/L!" Z..*# "&= 4%/L #R1Y9Z; ' #F"&F!" #"&_ 4E/ %" 95 " c@s" #.F [&5 ' %I"z 72* &@d 0] ED 0.: #("!. 4#R]9. ' d5 %" #- +* ;" [. &/S" >C" +/3H&I 41991) 7* #Y S #- +* /1.= /1.= Q"G" +:" +"&. 9:T %" +*d5.(military Balance, ) *R? #;&. 4F Ui'!" +2@i E"G/ #.!",' qs? /5 \;'' " 9/! %" *gc %/3'" 95 ;" &_d3l O= ' b1 O= O=. >C@o" G. +*O= 95 ;" %" ^@;" %" MT.",6" ( F Ui'!" 95 " +&@d/. 2@K" 4" ED. 9.d +/3H&I ' *# 0$? b1 95 #3K." b1 O= ON/F&. 9.d #1123"%/. ON/F& "&! w?. #i" 0$? &_ O=. >C@o" 9. ' G(#&. " +&_ >C@o" +/3H&I 95 #* 3'

12 1397 $%&' 4 "# Kim, 1991, 1992, 1996; Kugler & Tammen, ),' # F \F!" Z. ' *>C@o" ORV &. #15 Y9. F Ui' ~3A 2Z Y9. 4*# (1980).(2009; Lemke, 2002 &1(5 ' #$(" +'?. 9]! ED 95. +/15!K /;D k&? 4+"9:T!""dL!".@?" /5W.."# 0$? *>C@o" MT 9. ED!" #? &@d '. Q"G" K ]&;9. 7N" 7Z; ' "&_2* Š&@(9:T - #]9. 95 #.&ˆ +I'" 7.&6. y 4K%" 9RF' #@/" b."'!" +"9]26 6" 9. /;D k&? $&D ;/; 4/6" I'". >TZ /;D k&? #@/25&/ˆ +* 3'. (hub and spoke) b."' %/2* 7I&. &; \F!" pi ' $&D #C@o" 7$R? ORV «[&I ' &L» 9.,;.(Beeson, 2009: 98) ' : %/L ' 9. #@-N.&25 6" N.. %" " 4«[&I ' &L» #@/" 4%I"z 0? 9:T %" $&D >C@o" 9. [*0$? 2] +*d5. ;" 9@ /$N +*!" &@d "" 4U="'.@* 1!/ ' /3"&@;" 4I_; 4E" 4#.F &5 E/ #C@o" 7$R? ' +&R*" b."' +"&=&. #1P" &N 4%/L O5&N!" #? +/15. ;" 4$&D 4@/; b1 O=. 9:T %" +* 3'. /;D k&? #C@o" 7$R? ;# &-9. 4[/n/I +*@/; 7&- &. 9/$. 4K%". ~Zi ' ;B!" 9:T #@/" ' +6 +2Z ED #@5d &$' ' %/L #.O= 5d 70 'K &ik K %/L. ;" [? &[/n/i &_ +;!" $&D #R 7:T [N@ O^" E"N@ 0? 95 ;" [&5 "&=&. ~1@A +*d5. +&R*" F Ui'!" %/L i!" #"G/ ;" %$2 #?r2* %" '?# /;D k&? 9$" %/] +&R*" 5d ' >C@o" MT %/. >C@S" ".* l!. " +"9:T " 9:T %" +*d5. %/L 7RF' +* 5d ' $&D +&R* 9. >C@o" 7$R? /* ' 9:T %" +*d5 b."' /* #(/n/i ' +"? &. 45# "F *!" ' %?' Ui'!" %/L &_d3l O= +2@i ~/P >C@o" +/3H&I qs?!" [H@;" G. +*O=. b."' #da.< 9.,"G3" &R*" 4K%/]."G"# 9:T F b."' < ' /* 4?# R B/H/;I/;D 7:T +*d5!" +/. +;!" 95 [/n/i " F Ui'!" +2@i E"G/ #.!" 96/@ ' +"9:T - *d5 [/n/i +*@/; O= < ' E= 0P" ' hk #_@."' 4#R]9..5# 912F!" +"9:T BL5 +*O= #@K 4#5 95 ;" ED 5(!. O"&//J 6" 9. = #da.< 9.,"G3" &R*" &. 9/$. /;D k&? lf +*d5.@* +"9$R? b."' < ' /* E&5 [/n/i ' 9"&/_1ˆ ' #TS&/ˆ

13 1013 H 2D?CDDF :5F,G L6 'EA : = 5#,G L6 #;&. 91 %&. ;" +"9:T ' #1123"%/. +* 5d 4,; qs? #*"&2*!" F +*6* ' ]"= g&8i 4* %" &_d3l O= 5d!" #5K ' #F 4?# 4#1123"%/. jt;. /;& %/L #@5d +*@!" 95 +&.= +"&. gc %/] #1123"%/.. ;" H3A '.= F +*6* ' ]"=. #R #*"&2* ;" S U. ;@ +"9:T ' ]"= &//J.9L 4# F B. 4I #1123"%/. k'p En2* 3ˆ #1123"%/. +*. +$2* ' y] E F ' #"&(9RFL!" 2K 3= 01 E!; +* ' # F O6 E!; #.&ˆ +*O=. %/L #;/; /* 02] ". 95 +"9(9. ' 9Z; B. ' w(1396 4k'&N) «[F '.&25» ;" %/L 9F #RT=L ;" O'H@ #RT=L E F S; ' #"&(9RFL &Rd/I 4p$&. En2* #*$@." +&/_/I ' X&Y 4 y] 0123"%/. +* 3ˆ Q: E/d5 Q3L 9. +"&. " &@. 4%/L +;!" #/;D S;&! +"9:T +* 7RFL.(109 :1394 4k'&N ' #S&/?) 'D# $?" #! 9. S 7' +&/_2dL &//J 90 7* b;"'"!" 4 *"& #1Z b1 - &T/; ' 4%/L 9L&(" 4+"9:T &_# D 9. &. ' jt; ;/I# 95 " +&@d/. 02 E5" ' " Ed ED9;D + $?" cs Y9. ' * %" Kugler &. ) 5 5d /;D k&? lf ' k&? &;"&; #@/" ' +@=" +* ;" [/n/i ' R & %" di MT 4K%". «ED9;D ["» 912F!" /;D k&? #"&(9:T 4" [?" +*.(Organski, 2009; Beeson, 2009 (2015) /3 9nL A 71*' 3' #1 U!" &VW@ O?9. 95 ;" +$2* 9. #@$K %/. #@; /* #] %/L 5d 4&_ +;!"..# 3'" #1 U 4M" R OP ' ;" y] +"&. 95 #*[!K ' O]i &N +"!D!" " d5 %" 4+"9:T +* %"!" 2K F'. %/L» ;" :@Z %/n2* /3."#2!. 4" +N /2*" ED U U ' R. [. %$2 95 F&* " ED +* 95 [&5 gc 4ED9;D #"&(9:T!. 0$? 5 91 ' >H? + Z %".? 9 95 ED9;D *# d 9. 1!/ ' /3"&@;" 4* 4[N@ O^" '' Ed #.F %/L + d5 %" &/S" O"="!" [H@;",] 9. Z En2* F?9@&8I +*6* ' ]"= 9. qad!" #5K *"? 9$1. 4" 2002 ; #.F %/L + +@ ]"= 7/C]" &: '! ' #@/" Lim, 2015: ) #* F ]"= +$@; +"&. gc 95 ;" ED ;" +"9:T +*X&Y #1P" ' #@; &/!" O'H@ +&/ +@="

14 1397 $%&' 4 "# S&L 9. ZP +"&. O= ' Q: %/. /I +"&. &_d3l O= gc!" #da. 95.'# 2?9. O= #=!" +2@i E"G/ #.!" &_ qs? ' 9. (2009) % 3' ' &1(5 B//F 'D,"G3" +*_3" ' #/!&; Od= F' :!" ;" OR] 95 "[&5 [?" F Ui'!" +2@i 'D&. #/!&; OC@S" qs? 9. G/ E"&_d*')I!" #S&..+6 (2011) '"&.(Vasquez 1993; Huth 1996; Efrid et al, 2003) "[" Ed 9F F Ui' Od= %" 9. 4#.F %/L + Od= %/L S +*#.!" G/. ;" [&5 [?" +"9:T F Ui'!" %/L #@i +"&. #S? E"]9. (295, (3 & 9: %6.4 Ui'!" &_d3l O= +2@i jt; ' #R O= +*qs? ' *&/J@ #.!".*# "&= /;D k&? +&&. +"&. O1. #@.= " [N@ O^" ' %/L 4F G5& 9. E? 0R 4%/L #- +*9G*!? 4+"9:T "&911; jt; Ed #_2* 4+"9:T +*+!; ' ]"= &."&. d5 ' /;D +@=" O=. ;@ #d: +H" E*"S ' ;" #i" #1N F Ui'!" %/L 95 *# +F +"9:T &_d3l O= B,: 4%I"z!" %@&( #d/i %/] 4%"&... ;" S!* %/L ;# &- 9. 4# F "&911; jt; 4&_ +;!". ;" [&5 a ' ]"= 40/3 %/2* 9. ' ;" 0123"%/. ;/; 7NP +!. +"&. +&/( K O= E"]9. En2* ' d5#2 Q3L 9. +F OP9. " F #1123"%/. +*6* 71*' 5# 6" $&D +"&. 95 #d3l 4%"&...5# 02] F Ui'!" #i".. *"S +"9:T A +$2* ' 9]!!""dL ' O= "8( +"&. #2 +* 3^ 4[? & /;&!" #5K ^. & 4;B!".?" *"S!'&" [/n/i lll +"9:T ' # F "&911; "8( : Z ' +"9:T ' # F - +*_3" 0S" ' #TS OP9. "8( 7T: B 4O= "8(, H!" #@;?"&.. ;" O= +*[!K " "8( E? +"9S? E"# 4&_ +;!".?# [*d # F h/: %$2 95 &5 [*d O'H@ b1 +*O=. /" [)'9. ~1@A #]i 9. "8( /Zi'!" #? E. /; ' /ZT=,] 0/39. ;".«5# #? " * HF E/ +&R*" +!. {C2]» 95 *# 0$? #:@ - +_3"

15 1015 H 2D?CDDF :5F,G L6 'EA : = 5#,G L6 {C2] +*!" "&911; /Z="' (2014) h;"&. ' +&R$" ' E&5 ;. 95.(77-78 :1395 4#2;=) S# (2005) 5# 0R «#2@/; +&" 9. " "8(» 4#R]9. «" F' B/;C5 #)* M:N E$"» &_ dl 9. /;D k&? %/@G@5 En2* 7:T #"&(0/1N Xi'9. /Zi' %" 95 ;" 9:T %" %!'&" %" 9..'D# E/ 9. %A; 9:T %" +&R* ~/P «9(' 0S" %". ;" %/L. +@=" ' +6 +&R* ' 4[N@ O^". #@/" +&R* 95 Z O= &$12]!" #? ED &55!" #da. /;D k&? +"9:T ' # F - +_3" ' %" /:@ Y9. 95 ;" # F "&911; [N@O^" "'! 9. ' #3' b1 #da. ' 5# "&=&. 9:T %" +*K"'. /:@ +/I ' R" ' " 3S 9:T %" #' +*QI %/L a O= ' +G5& +*O= &$12]!" #? &_ B/@/1Ioz 7$R? #iz +@ +_3" 9. S &" %".( :1394 4k'&N) ;" 9:T %".?# &6 &/( +*K"' E/ B/5"oz 7$R? #@.= +@ +_3" '. 3' +!"&* &N +'&/ &_ 4#(/n/I /Zi' +&R*" ORV /- b"&? #"G"* 9$1. 4(Waltz, 1979)?#2 #:1 #- O= #15 U! &_ +* "&= C #*K"' %/L EC5 &R*" B/5"oz ' B/@/1Ioz +*&R*" E/ O^". #@/" b."' ' %/L. +@=" #"&_2* E!* TS &@5 +"&. gc. B/@/1Ioz!K * %/L 4%/n2* 3' 95.5# +Y9. 3'.&/(# R " [N@ '.&25» &R*". B/5"oz [!K ' #.F %/L + hk MY ' #CP" +&R*" +!"&* P +@=" E2/I ' B/H/;I/;D (RCEP) +*ld +"9:T [N@ &/("& +@=" 5d E2/I ' O^" «[F #- +C/@;" ' yk 0.:. ;" B/H/;Ip"& ;( [/n/i O= 7!" 7&- +"5 4? /5W ED &. 93: %" 9nD " w ;" #2@/; %/L 5%//R O= "8( 7&- 40/3 %/2* 9.. ;"!'&" #.?D ' #*&/J@ /n/i +*@/; 4U="'9.. ;" [. '9.' 0$ ' N 0K"&. O= "8( %//R!" G/ O= "8(, H!" #@;?"&. 95 &5 0123"%/. b."' O/." "' " +*@/; 7&- h;"&. # H +!;!. 9.!/ 40/3 %/2* 9.. ;" "5 % U=' E? +Z.L 4hK #_@."' 4"8( E? +"9S? En2* ED P" ' #.?D ' [/n/i %" /;D k&?." % +* /Z="' &. krt" +"&. E? #TS&/ˆ ' E. /; 4O=

16 1397 $%&' 4 "# ' # F "&911; "8( : Z 3= O"&//J %" ' S# dl 9. *#I $&D +&R*. 9(' "&911; Y9. w?# [*d /;D k&? 7:T "8( E? +"9S?!" #5K 95 ;" %$ %/L +&R* ' /"!K ORV &. S G/ #]i ' +@S; +*[!K "8( : Z. ;" #2@/; %/L \F ' Y."8(# &/VW &/( +*K"' EC5 +*&R*" +R E"]9. +&R*" /; &@25!'&" 9. R ' {2] ED &. 5K +@=" ' #@/" b/n 95 &; E5" " w. E;D R 9. #/;D +* 3' +"&. +&/(/2 ' +!"&* OR;N» 4. k&? /n/i ' S O2/2 +*/I ;" "? D +"&. 4m].«'D +' ١ +'93R 9!" +"&. O!" O" Z @]" /;D * "&= " N<i ' 9@( 4O[5 O2/2» *# j/f& >"*" F 5# R " #y=@ +* ;/; 3' B ;# &- 9. [( 95.(Jackson, 2014: ) «5# 02] Z@ ' E. /; 4#(/n/I 95?. kp #15 "G( %" &(" 4<26 /;D k&? 9(' 9. /Zi' %" ' &.# &; 9. O= #(5"&I +*"8(. ED #G_F ' O= "8( B/;C5, H +&_!. ' N 4*# 0$? Y9. /;D k&? 9:T ' 05 Y "%/. ;/; MT #.!" #TS&/ˆ ' +"9S? [&5 [?" #@;9. (2009) E/. 95 YE2* 496/@..# O'&i cs +;!" «[?9o"" +&- +*Q/.!" &[/n/i /. "8( ' B/)*.= /*» 4 ;" b1 O= +&R* 95 " F' 2@K" %" ' ;" O= "8( #@; E"!"&I9&- +$2* 9]! 2@K" &. S 95 &/( 0$? O'H@ Y9. ~1@A #]i +*[!K?R ["&2* \F. {'G3 O= "8( 7-N3 ;" %$2 ' "8(# &/VW ~1@A $?" 9..?. 9@?" F' B/;C5 #)* M:N E$" {C2] ' *Ĥ & <1! (>% #3 +"8_@;/; "& N ' +"9&;,- #3 E"&N.».(1394) 92Y 4k'&N w#1]2n 4#S&/? c 44 g 41 ' 4"?L;% C^F-" 4«# F ' OZ3T #_*& 7;` :E"& 4["!#/_L #1ZCˆ 72F& 4G '?CD5U V-:.(1389) n 40@/3.2.E"G/ :E"& 4O< b%5nd.&pz "&." #1123"%/. O:/:N :7"823 43?CD5U.(1393) *& 4#2;=.3 1. Bandwagoning

17 1017 H 2D?CDDF :5F,G L6 'EA : = 5#,G L6 -" 4«\F ' #("!. 4hK #_@."' +_3" :#.?D ' [/n/i +*@/;».(1395) *& 4#2;= c 4,; g 46I ' 49O C^F 4, L g 4@H* ; 4O< 43 4«Q]" :'& 92Y 4k'&N c g"g( 4«0123"%/. +@=" +$2* M:N %/L "? &/ :[F '.&25 d».(1396) 92Y 4k'&N c 4297 g 4bD^:5%,-: Y@5 O<?C>C^F 'Z +&R*" ( 7. Abdollahian, M. & Kang, K. (2008). in Search of Structure: The Nonlinear Dynamics of Power Transitions", International Interactions, 34:4, Beeson, M. (2009). Hegemonic Transition in East Asia? The Dynamics of Chinese and American Power, Review of International Studies, 35, Beeson, M. (2009). Hegemonic Transition in East Asia? The dynamics of Chinese and American Power, Review of International Studies, 35, pp Clowes, D. & Choroś-Mrozowska, D. (2015). Aspects of Global Security-the Measurement of Power & its Projection. Research from Twenty Selected Countries ( ), Journal of International Studies, 8, 1, pp Cudworth, E. & Hobden, S. (2010). Anarchy and Anarchism: Towards at Theory of Complex International Systems, Journal of International Studies, 39, 2, pp DiCicco J., Levy J (2003). Power transition Research Program, a Lakatosian Analysis, in Progress in International Relations Theory, by Colin Elman and Miriam Fendius Elman, MIT Press. 13. Fravel, M. (2011), China s Strategy in the South China Sea, Contemporary Southeast Asia, 33, 3, pp Hwan Lee, S. (2015) Global and Regional Orders in the 21st Century in Terms of Multi- Layered Power Transition Theory: The Cases of US-China and China-Japan Relations, International Area Studies Review,18, Ikenberry J. (2014). The illusion of Geopolitics: The Enduring Power of the Liberal Order, Foreign Affairs, 93, 3, pp Jackson, V. (2014) Power, Trust and Network Complexity, Three Logics and Hedging in Asian Security, International Relations of the Asia-Pacific, 14, Katzenstein, P. (2005). A World of Regions: Asia and Europe in the American Imperium, Ithaca, NY, Cornell University Press. 18. Kim W. (1991). Alliance Transitions and Great Power War. American Journal of Political Science, 35, 4, pp Kim W. (1992) Power Transitions and Great Power War From Westphalia to Waterloo, World Politics, 45, 1, pp Kim W (1996). Power parity, alliance, and war from 1648 to 1975, In: Kugler J, Lemke D (eds) Parity and War: Evaluations and Extensions of The War Ledger, Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press, pp Kugler, J. & Douglas Lemke. eds. (1996). Parity and War: Evaluations and Extensions of the War Ledger, Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press. 22. Lee, S.H. (2015). Global and Regional Orders in the 22st Century in Terms of Multi- Layered Power Transition Theory: the Cases of US-China and China-Japan Relations, International Area Studies Review, 18, 3, pp Lemke, D. (2002). Regions of War and Peace, New York: Cambridge University Press. 24. Lemke, D. & Suzanne Werner (1996). Power Parity, Commitment to Change, and War. International Studies Quarterly, 40, pp Levy, J.S. & Thompson, W.R. (2010). Balancing on Land and at Sea, International Security, 35, 1, pp Lim Y. (2015). How (dis) Satisfied is China? A Power Transition Theory Perspective, Journal of Contemporary China, 24, 92, pp Mearsheimer, J. (2010). The Gathering Storm: China s Challenge to US Power in Asia, The Chinese Journal of International Politics 3, 4, pp

18 1397 $%&' 4 "# Mearsheimer. J. (2001). The Tragedy of Great Power Politics, New York: Norton. 29. Military Balance. (2014). Available at: Mrotzek, M. (2011). Approaching the Tipping Point: Critical Transitions in Systems, 29 th International Conference of the System Dynamics Society. 31. Organski, A. F. K (1958). World Politics, New York: Alfred A. Knopf. 32. Organski, A. F. K & Jacek Kugler (1980). The War Ledger, Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press. 33. SIPRI Military Database Wagemann Jr, J. (2014). Chinese Grand Strategy: How Anti-Access/Area Denial (A2/AD) Fits in Chinas Plan, Air Command and Staff College Maxwell Air Force Base United States. 35. Waltz, K (1979). Theory of International Politics, Waveland press.

19 1019 H 2D?CDDF :5F,G L6 'EA : = 5#,G L6.1 7# ' 7"823 U my3?c,g N&,G E9 VO :""J Country Name Brazil China Germany India Japan Russian Federation United Kingdom United States Country Name Brazil China Germany India Japan Russian Federation United Kingdom United States Country Name Average from Brazil China Germany India Japan Russian Federation United Kingdom United States